A brief history of Pluto’s 87-year planetary identity crisis

A brief history of Pluto’s 87-year planetary identity crisis

View photo


“Doctor Slipher, I have found your Planet X.” On Feb. 18, 1930, this is what astronomer Clyde Tombaugh told his boss, Vesto Slipher. For years, scientists at the Lowell Observatory in Arizona had scanned million of stars in search of a fabled planet at the far reachers of our solar system. Tombaugh was now sure he had found it.

After taking more photos to confirm the finding, 87 years today, on March 13, 1930, the world was told that a new planet would be added to the solar system. It was named Pluto in part to honor Percival Lowell, as his initials would make up the first two letters of the name. Lowell was a wealthy businessman, mathematician, & astronomer who built observatory where Tombaugh & Slipher worked & where the search for Planet X began 24 years earlier.

Every successful relationship is successful for the same exact reasons

According to Powell, Planet X had to be out there, somewhere, because of wiggles in the orbits of Uranus & Neptune. The theory was that a large planet must be lurking beyond Neptune in order to create the gravitational tug that accounted for the orbital perturbations.

But almost as shortly as Pluto was discovered, astronomers began questioning its status as Planet X. It looked too small to create orbital perturbations. Over the next 50 years, Pluto’s mass was calculated, argued over, & then recalculated. In 1978, the discovery of Charon, Pluto’s moon, allowed a conclusive measurement of the planet’s mass, of approximately 1/500th of the Earth’s.

South Korea’s protest culture gets results, yet its roots are nothing to envy

Year calculated
1 Earth
9/10 Earth
1/10 Earth
1/40 Earth
1/100 Earth
1/500 Earth

Within a decade of that realization, based on data received from Voyager 2 as it crossed Neptune in 1989, Pluto’s status as Planet X was dealt a fatal blow. It turns out that Lowell’s original observations were slightly off, & Neptune’s mass had been overestimated by 0.5%. This seemingly tiny tweak meant that its orbital perturbations were not necessarily down to the pull of another planet in the vicinity.

What’s more, in the early 1990s a mess of bodies were discovered orbiting the sun, roughly in the same area & of the same size as Pluto. They even had similar skewed orbits as Pluto, which doesn’t orbit the sun in the same plane as the other eight planets of the solar system.

Indeed, given growing evidence, in 2006, the International Astronomical Union (IAU) demoted Pluto to a dwarf planet. Ejected from our solar system, Pluto now shares dwarf status with four other recognized planets & six other candidates.

In an ironic twist, the existence of these Pluto-like bodies & their skewed orbits have forced astronomers to start looking for a new Planet X. Last year, scientists announced that they believe a planet more massive than Earth, with a 10,000-year orbit around the sun, could be found quite soon.

Pluto’s identity crisis

As Quartz reported previously, a planet is defined by four characteristics:

According to the IAU, a full-fledged planet must: circle the sun without being some other object’s satellite; be rounded by its own gravity; not be so huge to undergo nuclear fusion like a star; & clear its neighborhood of most orbiting bodies.

It’s on the last measure that Pluto fails, because of the many similarly sized objects in its vicinity.

Still, there’s a small yet vocal contingent of scientists lobbying for Pluto to be considered a planet again. They were encouraged after NASA’s New Horizons mission took photos of the dwarf planet up close in 2015.

First, scientists spotted that Pluto might have clouds. Alan Stern, head of the New Horizons mission, said that, like in Star Trek, if space travelers saw a celestial body with clouds they would think it’s a planet. And, so, it must follow that clouds on Pluto should be enough to deem it a planet.

Then, just last month, a study published by Stern argued for expanding the definition of a planet: in effect, he says that any celestial body circling the sun with enough gravity to form a sphere should count. If he received his way, there would be 100 other celestial bodies (including our moon) that should be considered planets.

In the 87 years since we first discovered Pluto, we’ve learned a lot approximately the celestial body. We have moreover argued a lot approximately it. Regardless of its status, the frigid rock with a funky orbit will continue to enthrall scientists & stargazers for many years to come.

Read next: The dramatic way our view of Pluto has changed over the past 87 years


Sign up for the Quartz Daily Brief, our free daily newsletter with the world’s most significant & absorbing news.

More stories from Quartz:

With their ridiculously high salaries, unicorns may have ruined the job scene in the Indian tech sector
“This is India’s Uber”: Sexual harassment allegations rattle India’s top entertainment startup

Personal Finance – LifestyleSciencePercival LowellPlutoVesto Slipher

Source: “Quartz”

Share and Enjoy

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Delicious
  • LinkedIn
  • StumbleUpon
  • Add to favorites
  • Email
  • RSS